HomeNewsAn Undergraduate Education Challenge

HHMI News

An Undergraduate Education Challenge

Summary

HHMI is challenging research scientists to be more creative in teaching undergraduates. There is $20 million at stake for those who do.

The Howard Hughes Medical Institute (HHMI) has issued a challenge to science professors across the United States: Show the same ingenuity in your undergraduate teaching that you do in your scientific research.

HHMI announced today that it plans to award $1 million each to 20 research scientists on the basis of their plans to transmit the excitement and values of scientific research to undergraduate education. Those selected will become "HHMI Professors" and receive 4-year grants of $250,000 annually to apply their creativity and enthusiasm to undergraduate teaching. HHMI has invited 84 research universities to nominate tenured faculty members to compete for the grants, which it will award in the fall of 2002.

Institute President Thomas R. Cech explained why HHMI has issued the challenge. "Research is advancing at a breathtaking pace, but many college students are still learning science the same old way, by listening to lectures in large classes and memorizing facts from textbooks," he said. "We wish to empower scientists at research universities to become more involved and come up with really innovative ideas that 'break the mold' and take a fresh look at science education."

HHMI has kept the guidelines for the new awards flexible, to encourage applicants to be as creative as possible. The nominated scientists might propose, for instance, to teach freshman science courses in a laboratory setting, use the Internet to create new learning materials, establish interdisciplinary research teams that include undergraduates, mentor postdoctoral fellows in how to teach undergraduates effectively-or something else entirely.

"HHMI seeks to develop a cadre of scientist-educators who will become leaders in undergraduate teaching as well as research," Cech explained. "The HHMI Professors and their teaching strategies will serve as models for fundamental change both on their own campuses and elsewhere, helping to support and encourage research universities in their efforts to enhance undergraduate education. We don't know what to expect in the proposals, but we do expect them to be exciting."

This is the first time that HHMI will award undergraduate science education grants to individuals. Through its undergraduate biological sciences education program, HHMI has awarded $476 million since 1988 to colleges and universities to enhance life sciences education, notably by expanding undergraduate research opportunities, adding new courses and faculty, and reaching out to the K-12 education community.

The Howard Hughes Medical Institute is a medical research organization whose principal mission is the conduct of biomedical research. Approximately 340 Hughes investigators conduct medical research in HHMI laboratories at 72 of the nation's leading research centers and universities. Through its complementary grants program, HHMI supports science education in the United States and a select group of researchers abroad.

Invited Institutions

Baylor University

Tufts University

Boston College

Tulane University

Boston University

University of Arizona

Brandeis University

University of California-Berkeley

Bringham Young University

University of California-Davis

Brown University

University of California-Irvine

California Institute of Technology

University of California-Los Angeles

Carnegie Mellon University

University of California-Riverside

Case Western Reserve University

University of California-San Diego

College of William and Mary

University of California-Santa Barbara

Columbia University

University of California-Santa Cruz

Cornell University

University of Chicago

Dartmouth College

University of Colorado at Boulder

Duke University

University of Flordia

Emory University

University of Georgia

George Washington University

University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

Georgetown University

University of Iowa

Georgia Institue of Technology

University of Kansas

Harvard University

University of Maryland, Baltimore County

Howard University

University of Maryland, College Park

Indiana University at Bloomington

University of Miami

Johns Hopkins University

University of Michigan-Ann Arbor

Lehigh University

University of Minnesota

Louisiana State University and A&M; College

University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

Loyola University of Chicago

University of Notre Dame

Massachusetts Institute of Technology

University of Oklahoma

Miami University

University of Oregon

Michigan State University

University of Pennsylvania

New York University

University of Pittsburgh

Northwestern University

University of Puerto Rico-Rio Piedras

Ohio State University

University of Rochester

Pennsylvania State University

University of Southern California

Princeton University

University of Texas at Austin

Rensselaer Ploytechnic Institute

University of Utah

Rice University

University of Virginia

Rutgers University, New Brunswick

University of Washington

Saint Louis University

University of Wisconsin-Madison

Stanford University

Vanderbilt University

SUNY at Binghamton

Wake Forest University

SUNY at Buffalo

Washington University

SUNY at Stony Brook

Yale University

Texas A&M; University

Yeshiva University

Background: Undergraduate Science Education at Research Universities The Problem

  • Undergraduates who study science at research universities often find themselves in large lecture halls being taught by the most junior faculty. Their interaction tends to be limited with the prominent research scientists who helped the university earn its reputation.
  • The 2001 National Survey of Student Engagement reports that only 25 percent of seniors across all majors at doctoral-intensive universities work with professors on research outside of course requirements. (George D. Kuh, professor of higher education, Indiana University at Bloomington and director of the National Survey of Student Engagement .)
  • Many undergraduates take no more than one year of science, often in introductory courses. (National Research Council, " Transforming Undergraduate Education in Science, Mathematics, Engineering and Technology .")
  • The nation's research universities comprise only 3 percent of all institutions of higher learning, yet they confer 32 percent of all baccalaureate degrees and 56 percent of the baccalaureates earned by students who go on to graduate study in science and engineering. ( The Boyer Commission on Educating Undergraduates in the Research University , 1998. )

Causes of the Current Situation
Why don't researchers spend more time teaching undergraduates? The Boyer report notes that:

  • Tenure and promotion decisions tend to be based almost entirely on research and publication rather than on teaching.
  • National scientific meetings rarely offer sessions dealing with effective teaching. When they do, the sessions are often poorly attended.
  • University budgets usually adhere to the principle of departmental hegemony. As a result, interdisciplinary collaborations that might include undergraduates often are doomed for lack of departmental sponsorship.

Possible Solutions
The Boyer Commission made several interesting recommendations, including these:

  • Reconfigure the freshman year to include a small seminar taught by research faculty who can imbue new students with the excitement of discovery and provide opportunities for intellectual growth.
  • Pair undergraduates with mentors as early as possible and maintain those relationships throughout their academic careers.
  • Prepare students by their senior year to undertake research of the same character and complexity as that done by first-year graduate students. Even those who do not go on to graduate school will be well served as citizens by learning to solve problems analytically.

Models for Change

  • Since 1988, HHMI has awarded more than $475 million in grants to enhance undergraduate science education. The University of Arizona now considers a faculty member's commitment to undergraduate research in granting tenure. Colgate University has replaced "cookbook" experiments with research that can generate results of publishable quality. Cornell University has created a program that exposes freshmen to research. The University of Miami invites local community-college students to join research teams of its faculty members. (Thomas R. Cech, HHMI president, article in the Chronicle of Higher Education, 2/16/01)
  • More than half of all undergraduates at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology take part in an undergraduate research program. (Boyer Commission)
  • Undergraduates at the University of Chicago participate in a variety of research projects for which they receive either academic credit or a salary. (Boyer Commission)
  • The Georgia Institute of Technology has committed $250,000 to help faculty members involve more undergraduates in research projects.( Chronicle of Higher Education, 11/17/2000 ;)
  • Some universities have developed effective programs to help minority students succeed in the sciences. In a recent article , Freeman A. Hrabowski and Michael F. Summers described their "formula for success" at the University of Maryland Baltimore County.

HHMI's New Program
The Howard Hughes Medical Institute (HHMI) has issued a challenge to 84 research universities to nominate tenured professors with active research programs to compete for $20 million in grants. Those selected will receive $1 million each over four years to help "break the mold" in science education and strengthen the ties between researchers and undergraduates. 

For More Information

Jim Keeley
[ 301.215.8858 ]